ISDA paper warns of the dangers if EU/UK derivatives trading venues fail to agree on equivalence

Valdis Dombrovskis, executive vice-president in charge of financial policy, European Commission.

Although the European Commission has granted an 18 month reprieve on clearing, it is “critical” that the EU and the UK hammer out an agreement on equivalence for their derivatives trading venues after the Brexit transition period ends on 31 December,  according to a new paper from the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA).

The paper, which looks at the effect of Brexit on the derivative trading obligation (DTO), said failure to do so would cause “significant issues” for counterparties subject to the DTO and regulations. It would likely “exacerbate the fragmentation of liquidity in over-the-counter derivatives markets between the European Union and the UK resulting from Brexit,” it adds.

The paper notes that in the event that equivalence is not granted, derivatives trading venues “will face conflicting requirements” where the derivatives fall within the scope of the EU and UK DTOs (in-scope derivatives).

The biggest impact would be on the most liquid euro, US dollar and sterling interest rate swaps and index credit default swaps (CDS).

ISDA points out that a clash will arise where those EU and UK counterparties wish to trade with each other in in-scope derivatives on a cross-border basis or where an EU counterparty trades in in-scope derivatives through a branch in the UK with a UK counterparty, or vice versa.

As a result, the papers recommends the EU and the UK must recognise the equivalence of each other’s derivatives trading venues and to ensure that UK and EU exchange-traded derivatives are not re-characterised as OTC derivatives for the purposes of the European Markets Infrastructure Regulation as it applies in the EU and the UK.

This week, the European Commission gave banks and other financial market participants in the EU until mid-2022  to cut their dependency on London based clearing houses for derivatives transactions.

Valdis Dombrovskis, the European Commission’s executive vice-president in charge of financial policy, said, “This time-limited decision has a very practical rationale, because it gives EU market participants the time they need to reduce their excessive exposures to UK-based CCPs [central clearing counterparties], and EU CCPs the time to build up their clearing capability.”

He added that, “this time-limited decision has a very practical rationale, because it gives EU market participants the time they need to reduce their excessive exposures to UK-based CCPs, and EU CCPs the time to build up their clearing capability.”

London dominates the European market for swaps and futures clearing, handling the bulk of the €735tn market. The main players are LCH, part of the London Stock Exchange, ICE Europe and LME Clear. By contrast, Europe has few alternative venues to cope with the volume of business.

According to the Bank of England, as of August 2020, there were £60 trn pounds ($76.93 trillion) of derivative contracts between clearers in Britain and their EU members, with £43 trn of this due to expire after December.

©BestExecution 2020

UK regains top position for on venue GBP IRS

UK trading venues have regained their position as the biggest location for on-venue execution...

TradeTech: Nine out of ten traders favour permanent hybrid working

By Gill Wadsworth. Nine out of ten traders favour a permanent hybrid working model post-pandemic,...

TradeTech: Should AI be allowed into live markets?

Artificial intelligence is not ready to go into live markets, according to one panel...

UK regains top position for on venue GBP IRS

UK trading venues have regained their position as the biggest location for on-venue execution...

TradeTech: Nine out of ten traders favour permanent hybrid working

By Gill Wadsworth. Nine out of ten traders favour a permanent hybrid working model post-pandemic,...

TradeTech: Should AI be allowed into live markets?

Artificial intelligence is not ready to go into live markets, according to one panel...